Are electric cars cheaper to run than petrol or diesel cars?

12 minute read

electric vehicle being charged

Find out whether electric cars are cheaper in the long run as we go through upfront costs, charging, servicing, and insurance.

Comparing the cost of running electric, petrol and diesel cars

The table below compares the cost of running an electric car versus petrol and diesel. Overall ownership costs vary depending on where you charge, driving habits and usage, but there’s a good chance you’ll find an electric car cheaper than petrol or diesel.

Please note: the information and prices listed below are correct at time of writing but may change in the future.

 

Electric car running costs vs petrol and diesel

Cost factor

Electric car

Petrol car

Diesel car

Energy/fuel costs

Usually lowest when charged at home

Higher than electric due to fuel prices

Price at the pump higher than petrol, but better fuel economy evens it out. Likely to be more costly than electric car charging if home-charged

Servicing and maintenance

Generally lower due to fewer moving parts

Typically higher than electric, but lower than diesel

Higher than electric and petrol because of more complex maintenance

Insurance

Varies by vehicle and driver

Varies by vehicle and driver

Varies by vehicle and driver

Cost per mile

Usually lowest, if using a home charger

Typically higher than electric, but lower than diesel

Usually highest due to fuel prices and if ULEZ charges are applicable

Upfront purchase price

Higher purchase prices, also available via personal contract purchase (PCP)/personal contract hire (PCH) deals. Used electric vehicles (EVs) are an option too

Lower purchase prices, though PCP and PCH deals similar to electric cars

Lower purchase prices, though PCP and PCH deals similar to electric cars

Home charger installation

Additional upfront cost, though some manufacturers and energy suppliers offer a free home charger

Not required

Not required

Overall running costs

Often cheaper for drivers who can charge at home and do moderate to high mileage

Usually higher than electric

Slightly higher than petrol due to servicing, maintenance, and cost per mile  

 

Fuel and charging costs

A home charger is the best way to minimise the cost of charging an electric car. Many electricity suppliers offer EV owners discounted overnight rates or a specific EV rate for use at any time of the day. These can be as much as 80% cheaper than the peak rate.

With cheaper home charging available, the costs of an electric car compared with petrol or diesel look considerably lower. British Gas says the average cost of home charging an electric car for a range of 220 miles is £17. At a price of £1.70 per litre, it would cost about £38 to cover the same distance in a petrol car returning an average 45 miles per gallon (MPG). At £2 per litre, a diesel returning 50MPG would cost about £40.

 

Maintenance and servicing costs

An electric car has fewer moving parts beneath the bonnet, which makes routine maintenance more straightforward and tends to bring servicing costs down. According to The Car Expert, the average annual servicing cost for an electric car in the first three years of ownership is £545. The equivalent for petrol and diesel cars is £757.

Bear in mind that many electric cars will be purchased new or nearly new, meaning they may still be under the manufacturer’s warranty. That can reduce the maintenance costs because unplanned repairs may be covered by the warranty.

Because of their instant power delivery and greater weight, electric cars can wear through tyres and suspension components more quickly than petrol and diesel cars. Taken in the round, though, servicing costs for an electric car are likely to be lower.

 

Insurance costs

A report by the BBC states that it can cost between 10% and 25% more to insure an electric car than a petrol or diesel vehicle. This is because accident repair costs can be as much as 30% higher due to the complexity of the components that can be damaged, and repairs can take an average 14% longer to perform.

Insurance companies calculate premiums on the basis of several factors. Your car’s engine type will be considered alongside things like your age, driving record and location. Therefore, don’t be put off by insurance costs for an electric car.

 

How much does it cost to charge an electric car?

To calculate the cost of charging an electric car, you need to know the unit charge from your electricity supplier, as well as the size of your car’s battery and the time it takes to charge it. Broadly speaking, the larger your car’s battery, the higher the cost to charge it. But a bigger battery equates to a longer range, so you’ll be able to go further on a single charge and may save money by avoiding public charging points.

Cost of charging an electric car at home

With electricity suppliers like EDF charging as little as 6.66p per kWh on its off-peak EV tariff, a home-charging point is the best way to minimise the cost of charging an electric car.

An off-peak tariff could bring the cost of an overnight charge in at around £4 for a small hatchback like the Renault 5 E-Tech, with a range of just under 200 miles. A larger car like Renault’s Megane E-Tech would cost around £7.30 to charge off-peak, giving a range of 350-plus miles.

Cost of charging at public charging stations

If you don’t have a home charger, the cost of charging an electric car goes up. The average rate for public charging in the UK is 54p per kWh, with rapid chargers at places like motorway service stations as much as 85p per kWh. These can top your car up to 80% battery in less than half an hour, so are worth the premium if you’re on a long journey and don’t want to hang around.

Another option is to use an employer’s charging point, as these are often subsidised or free for staff members. Or you could rent someone else’s charger via a company like Co Charger. You’ll pay more than a home-charging tariff to charge your electric car, but less than at a public charger.

 

What about the upfront costs of an electric car?

As technology develops and the range of electric cars increases, prices are becoming comparable to their petrol/diesel counterparts, though all-electric models still tend to cost more upfront.

As an example, here are the starting On The Road (OTR) prices for the Peugeot 208.

Series

Petrol

Hybrid

Electric

Peugeot 208

£20,565

£24,415

£25,065

 

The all-electric model is the most expensive. However, it would qualify for a £1,500 government grant (£3,750 for some other electric cars, depending on the environmental credentials of their production processes). So, in this scenario, the grant would help bring the electric model more in line with the hybrid engine and make it only a little more expensive than the petrol.

For many, the outright purchase price of an electric car is irrelevant because they’ll pay for it using finance. This could be through PCH (Personal Contract Hire), where you lease the car for an agreed term. Alternatively, you could use PCP (Personal Contract Purchase), where monthly payments accrue against the car’s value, with an option to buy at the end of the term. In either case, the relevant figure is the deposit and monthly charge, which is often no higher for an electric car than for a petrol or diesel vehicle.

 

Cost of installing a home charger

A basic home charger typically costs between £500 and £1,000, with the same again for installation. Some suppliers offer an installation package that reduces the overall cost. It’s worth getting quotations before you agree to anything, as installing a charging point can require additional cabling that brings extra cost.

If you’re a tenant or live in a leasehold property, or only have access to on-street parking, you may qualify for a £500 government grant towards the installation of a home-charging point. Homeowners with off-street parking don’t receive the grant, though some manufacturers – including Ford, Volvo and Volkswagen – offer a free home charger as part of a new-car deal, as do energy companies such as Octopus and EDF.

Hidden costs of owning an electric car

There are some hidden costs associated with owning electric cars. These offset some of the savings made in other areas, though most EV owners agree they are better off overall.

Thanks to their relative newness, there’s some uncertainty about residual values for electric cars, not least because of concerns over battery durability. An influx of new vehicle manufacturers offering cheaper electric cars, such as Leapmotor, BYD and Jaecoo, has disrupted the market and led to further price uncertainty. So, an EV may lose value more quickly than a petrol or diesel model.

However, the recent spike in fuel prices has subdued the value of traditional combustion-engined cars, making the depreciation of electric cars look less steep.

Another hidden cost is over-reliance on public charging points, given their higher prices. This can be an issue if you’re unable to install a home charger, or your workplace can’t offer affordable charging to staff.

Battery replacement

While battery degradation is a concern among owners of electric cars, a study by Which? shows it is a relatively minor issue. Its survey of 4,000 electric car owners revealed that battery capacity had only dropped by an average of 6% over seven years of use. For most motorists, especially those buying their vehicles on time-limited finance agreements, the cost of replacing their electric car battery will not be a concern.

Further reassurance comes from the fact that manufacturers are required by law to provide a minimum eight-year or 100,000-mile warranty on electric car batteries. So, even if you did need to replace the battery on your electric car, there’s a good chance the cost would be covered by the manufacturer.

 

How your driving habits affect electric car running costs

Electric cars aren’t for everyone, but there is a category of motorist for whom they make a lot of sense. If you’re able to charge at home most of the time and regularly undertake journeys within your vehicle’s range, you’ll definitely find an electric car cheaper to run.

Here’s a summary of the potential electric car savings you could make:

Driver type

Potential EV savings

Low-mileage drivers (under 5,000 miles annually)

Savings less noticeable, as petrol or diesel fuel costs are already relatively low

Occasional drivers

Savings depend on home-charging access and frequency of use rather than mileage alone

Drivers with home charging

Often benefit from the lowest running costs and greatest long-term savings

High-mileage drivers

Typically see the biggest savings from lower energy and maintenance costs

 

As mentioned above, how you charge your electric car makes a big difference in savings. Drivers with home charging often benefit from the lowest running costs and the greatest long-term savings.

Are hybrid cars cheaper to run?

If an all-electric car isn’t for you, a hybrid may be an option. Standard hybrids use a mix of a petrol or diesel engine and a self-charging battery, so there’s never a need to plug into a charger. Plug-in hybrids offer greater range on battery power alone, but do need charging to ensure optimal efficiency.

If your lifestyle permits, you’ll save the most money by choosing an all-electric car – as Isaac Randall, director of Randalls Financial Advice, discovered. He advises clients on making their retirement income go further and says: “With the right deal on home charging, an electric car is much cheaper than petrol, diesel or hybrid, making it a good choice for older drivers. I made the switch for my car and my wife’s car, and we haven’t looked back.”

Are electric cars worth buying?

Electric cars can cost less to run than petrol or diesel cars. Charging is cheaper than refuelling and maintenance is often less expensive.

The precise savings depend on factors such as:

  • Your mileage
  • Driving habits
  • Charging arrangements
  • Cost of purchasing or leasing your vehicle

This means you could save on the costs of motoring by choosing an electric car.

It’s also worth bearing in mind that the UK Government is phasing out the sale of new petrol and diesel vehicles.  From 2030, all new cars will need to be hybridised in some manner or be zero emission.

If you’re getting ready to make the switch, we hope this guide has demonstrated that electric cars can bring plenty of benefits. You can read about one driver’s experience of going electric here.

We occasionally link out to other websites which we believe are helpful for our readers. We are not responsible for the content on third party websites.

CI2344R1OCT26